Skip to main content

Roman Zozulya, Milo Yiannopoulos and ideology. (2nd March, 2017)

I've been avoiding this topic, but things are just getting ridiculous now and I wanted to give a very quick take on it.

Yesterday was the deadline for Zozulya to "return" to Rayo. Now, there have been a lot of disagreeements. Rayo fans don't want him in the team. Tebas and Presa are willing to charge fans who drove Zozulya out. And the Agrupación de Peñas del Rayo, or la Plataforma ADRV, has called for an assembly in the Rayo locker room to resolve the situation, whether that means Zozulya plays at Rayo or somewhere else.

But among all the chaos, what was most striking was Toño's recent interview, where he said something very simple but very important. "We must also consider that if he comes we will have to accept it in the best possible way and if he can contribute by scoring goals we must treat him as part of the team, regardless of ideological thoughts."

If the left loves one thing, it is the idea of free speech and safe spaces where anyone can speak their mind. But is there a line between free speech and consequence-free speech? Maybe, but some might argue that all speech has a consequence - that it is being heard. More contentiously, what is the line between opinions that are contentious and opinions that are harmful?

For example, Milo Yiannopoulos lost his book deal when he stated opinions in favor of pedophilia. The questions arises - is that the line? Does bullying transgenders count as free speech?

The hypocrisy of some on the left, sometimes called the "regressive left", is that while they seek to say "don't look at people as a monolith", they treat everyone who disagrees with them as a monolith. But then the question becomes, what is the line between understanding an opposing point of view and accepting it? In the Zozulya case, fans are currently saying that someone who supports a far-right group is not welcome. Is that hypocritical coming from a community that arose from immigrants and whose central message is that everyone is welcome?

There are too many questions, a lot of finger-pointing and very few answers. But the interview by Toño is amazing - he was looking at a sporting aspect and giving an answer on sporting terms but basically gave an answer to a very difficult political question on political terms.

He said that any player who contributes to the team, and any one who contributes to a community, is welcome. Regardless of ideological thoughts.

Maybe Toño was just trying to diffuse a tricky situation. In another way, maybe he is more radical than the fans.

And maybe he is right.

A post-thought: I love looking at things from the other side. What I find scary is not that some fans think that Zozulya is extreme, but that Zozulya most probably things that the fans are being extreme.

And even scarier is the thought that Zozulya might be more justified. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hinchas y Jugadores - Gimnàstic with Marius Helgå (14th May, 2017)

Marius Helgå is a 40 year old Gimnàstic fan who lives in Oslo. He is originally from Mo i Rana, Norway (1000 km north from Oslo). He has two hobbies: "playing bass trombone and watching football." 

He runs the Twitter account @nasticnoruega for Gimnàstic fans in Norway. As if he wasn't hipster enough, he also supports Stålkameratene who are in the fifth level of Norwegian football. Not to mention Tromsø (Norwegian top level), Manchester United, Juventus and Eintracht Frankfurt.

Follow him on Twitter here.



How long have you been a fan of Gimnàstic and what made you support them in the first place?

I visited Tarragona on a trip to Spain in 2006, and immediately fell in love with the city. As I didn’t have a club I supported in Spain then, it was an easy choice to start supporting the club.

Given the transfer windows and the squad that was assembled at the start of the season, is Gimnàstic where you want it to be?

After a great 2015-16 season, I was really expecting more of Nàs…

Hinchas y Jugadores - An exclusive interview with Román Golobart (1st May, 2017)

When did you make the decision to pursue football and what motivated you to do so?

I never realized I took a decision, since a very young age I knew that would be my life so I took it for granted that I was going to become a footballer.

The motivation was nothing other than enjoying it a lot!

What were your initial thoughts when you were at Espanyol and Wigan became interested in you, and what motivated you to move to England?

Both moments were very satisfactory. I went to a summer camp that Espanyol organizes and after it I got a letter from the club. I was excited, willing to do it - I was nervous, but the kind of nervous that one gets when you know you have a nice challenge ahead.

With Wigan it was a call, but still a very similar reaction. The thing with Wigan was that even though I was bad in English class, I knew I would end up going to England to play football so I didn't bother paying attention as I knew I would learn it there. And so it happened.

Did you find it difficult t…

From Catalonia to Heybridge - the story of an eighth division club (19th October, 2017)

After spending his whole life at UDA Gramenet and a season at Europa, Guillem Ramón moved to Terrassa in the summer of 2014. It was just another Catalan player transferring between two clubs in the Catalan regional leagues - nothing extraordinary.

But it was consequential.

In March 2015, in a match against Sabadell, the full back suffered a complete meniscal rupture, and his season was over. So was his contract - and a big chunk of the 2015-16 season as well. He ended up signing for Cerdanyola, without pay (as he was recuperating), and the doctors said that January would be his return time. However, he debuted in November.

In hindsight, it was a mistake.

After two games, in a training session, on November 25th he got injured again - this time in the quadriceps in the same leg. After two months of recuperation, and still no guarantee of pay, Guillem left for new pastures in February 2016. A trial at Coplestonians FC followed; so did an opportunity at Needham Market FC, in the seventh t…